Purple Caterpillar

Sunday, May 21, 2006

vinyl as an alternative to leather

I was just exploring the vegan lunchbox, a fun blog that I explore every once in awhile to get good food ideas. In a recent post with a baseball theme the author mentioned being able to get vinyl baseball gloves at target for a good price. I've been a vegan for probably about 10 years now and am still struggling with the leather alternatives. Is vinyl really better than leather? Both materials have an environmental toll. Which is really worse? In some recent research on window casings I read the following "Installing new windows will save a lot of energy. But just say no to vinyl. Its production requires massive amounts of chlorine, and its manufacturing and disposal release dioxin, a toxic substance that can cause cancer, endometriosis, and other diseases. Recognizing that there is no known “safe” level of dioxin, some European governments have called for alternatives to vinyl, while businesses such as Nike, General Motors, and Ikea are moving to reduce or eliminate it from their product lines." Yikes that makes vinyl sound pretty bad. But how does it compare in other products like baseball gloves? Leather uses some pretty nasty chemicals in the tanning process, plus it is, of course, animal hide which is what many vegans object too. But one of the major reasons that I eat a vegan diet is because I don't like the environmental impacts of the dairy industry. I need to do some more research but vinyl doesn't seem to be the best of alternatives. What else is there and which is the lesser of two evils leather versus vinyl??

Labels:

Wednesday, May 10, 2006

Local vs. Vegan

I have been vegan now for almost 10 years. It started when I was in grad school. I had been more or less vegetarian for a couple of years and was doing research on vegetarianism so that I could intelligently answer the "why" question which all vegetarians and vegans get asked on a regular basis. The more I read the more I felt that I was hypocritical to be vegetarian without being vegan. The best example of this is the source of veal. Many people (both Vegetarian and not) avoid veal because of the inhumane treatment of the calf before it is slaughtered for veal. It turns out in most cases the calves for veal come from the dairy industry. They are the male cows born to the milking heifers that the dairy farm has no use for (males obviously won't grow up to produce milk). As I drove the back roads in Wisconsin I could see the small crates for these veal calves lined up along the driveways of the diary farms. Another example is the pollution that the dairy industry causes. First milk is a waste of energy and water, it takes a large amount of grain and other foodstuffs cycled through cows to produce a relatively small amount of milk. Second the production of milk is a large source of water pollution, a dairy cow produces 120 pounds of waste a day and this waste is polluting underground waterways, rivers, streams, and even larger bodies of water such as the Chesapeake Bay. Since grad school I have continued to educate myself about environmental and food issues. Today, I am a fervent believer in local foods. I buy my produce in the summer from a local CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) and throughout the year I try to buy foods that are not highly processed and are grown and produced as close to home as possible. Even food produce in the US travels on average over 1000 miles before it reaches a plate. That is a lot of energy consumption and waste.

Thus my latest dilemma is what is truly better veganism or ovo-lacto vegetarianism using locally produced dairy and eggs from sustainable farms? For example, I can get milk that is produced very close to home or I can buy soy milk produced for soy grown in Iowa, shipped to a factory somewhere else, bottled and then shipped to my local grocer? That sure is an awful lot of energy and pollution to get that soy milk to me? Is it really less pollution and energy consumption than the local milk? Thus I find myself stuck trying to figure out what really is the better solution. Perhaps it is what I have always believed, that we all just need to treat dairy as a delicacy and not consume it at such large quantities as most Americans do. But how does that help me determine where to spend my money and what to put in my body? I've avoided dairy for all these years to make my point—that I don't want to support that industry and that are current agricultural system, especially for dairy and meat, is not sustainable. But wouldn't buying local New England milk be more sustainable than Iowa grown soy milk? ugh...

Labels: ,